Some generous offers are just hot air

In a Ha’aretz article by Lili Galili, Lieberman: Transfer Arab areas of J’lem to Palestinians, former minister Avigdor Lieberman (National Union Party) said he supports the transfer of some of Jerusalem’s Arab neighborhoods and Israeli Arab communities over to Palestinian control in conjunction with the establishment of a Palestinian state.

“Lieberman’s position on the transfer of Arab areas over to Palestinian control is part of his recently-formulated vision for a Jewish state based on ethnic separation from the Palestinians.

-I don’t want to pay national insurance to residents of these neighborhoods. The Palestinians should provide them with national insurance, labor representation and the right to strike,- Lieberman said.

Lieberman also said that, unlike left-wing activists back the People’s Voice and Geneva Initiative, he is not seeking peace but security and is not seeking a partner for the creation of a Palestinian state but rather a partner for the resolution of what he called “the problem of Arabs in the Land of Israel.

-I don’t want to be part of the ‘New Middle East,’ I want to be a representative of Europe in this region. I am not excited by eating hummus in Damascus but rather prefer walking around in Paris and London.-“

Well, I ask how one can represent Europe if one is in the Middle East? But, the real issue is not whether or not such an event will take place. We all know that is will not. The problem will be the internal Israeli acceptance of two concepts: transfer of Arabs, or in lieu of that, to accept the idea that Arabs within Israeli society are a foreign element and “eating hummus” is something which really cultured and refined people don’t do.

Another idea is that there will be “some” concessions to be made, and since Jerusalem will probably gain international status should ever a Palestinian State be created, there is a statement on record for the willingness to concede EVEN PARTS OF JERUSALEM!

If any areas are “given” over to Palestinian governance, we will be certain that they are someplace in the Negev.


3 responses to “Some generous offers are just hot air

  1. the article hints at what i think is one of the most serious critiques of the two-ethnic-state solution: the fate of “foreign elements”, individuals identified as belonging to an ethnicity not affiliated with the state. i.e. palestinian citizens in israel, settlers in palestine, and all non-israeli, non-palestinian residents of either, which now includes many exploited “guest workers” in israel, among many other small groups and some bigger ones, like the druze. the logic of the two-state solution dictates that palestinians inside israel be banished to palestine, that the settlers be banished to israel, and that other groups suffer state-based discrimination. in a world that’s becoming more integrated, solutions based on ethnic states are backward-looking.

  2. If Lily Galili is writing about it, that probably means that it is a case of Lieberman playing to the Russian Israeli voters. Russophone politics is Lily’s speciality (though she did do a little foray into refusnik anarchist politics a year ago or so).

    Talking of Russian Zionism, readers of the language will find this archive item totally mind-blowing – Dugin-influenced zionism a la evola:
    Polar Israel

  3. That’s irritating, it seems to have vanished. The Internet Archive may be acting up or it may be an error in the way I copied the link, which is
    I am especially interested in the link between certain elements on the Israeli Zionist Right Wing and Putin’s entourage. In fact I have a lot of data on this. What these Zionists do is present themselves to the Russians as allies against America, believe it or not, and certain elements around Putin (in the FSB) pretend to fall for this ploy.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s